Saw it. Liked it. Not sure if I
loved it. It's too dark visually, there's too much lovey-dovey, not enough mayhem, and some of the casting is simply weird. Yet I'm finding myself turning a lot of it over in my mind.
Brandon Routh is good as the Man of Steel, but they don't let him flex his muscles enough -- literally or figuratively. The biggest and best action sequence is near the beginning, and while we're treated to some derring-do after that, it's nothing
spectacular. Routh also doesn't get a lot of speaking time, which is odd, because he's pretty good when he does speak.
Kevin Spacey makes a damn good Lex Luthor in my mind. He doesn't quite have the panache of Gene Hackman's rendition, but he's effective at portraying a cold-blooded snake of a villain.
Lois Lane is where the movie sort of broke down for me. Kate Bosworth is certainly a looker, and I'm not questioning her acting chops. But Lois has morphed from a frenetic but likeable star reporter to a sullen, moody bitch. Margot Kidder wasn't beautiful per se, but she conveyed a spunky attractiveness that made her death in the first movie believably tragic for Superman. I guess we're supposed to think the Superman's extended absense has taken a heavy toll on Ms. Lane, but it's hard to reconcile the perpetual grump we see now with the charismatic go-getter of the past.
A final casting quibble is with the choice of Frank Langella as Daily Planet editor Perry White. Langella has a somewhat sinister screen presence, and his blandish performance upends the images of news editors as cigar-chomping lovable assholes we've seen from Jackie Cooper (who played White in the original "Superman") or J.K. Simmons (as J. Jonah Jameson in "Spider-Man"). Just didn't work for me.
Still, I find it hard to fault the movie as a whole. It's wonderful entertainment, and fairly thoughtful entertainment at that. It's the first good Superman movie in nearly 25 years. Superman was probably my favorite superhero growing up, and the first movie was almost as definitive a cultural event in my life as "Star Wars". His simple credo of truth, justice and the American way is one that can serve us well in these complicated and often dark times. Superman doesn't kill and he doesn't torture, but he gets the bad guys no matter what. "I never lie," he tells Lois Lane in the first movie. I use that on my own kid today when he fibs or tries to wriggle out of taking responsibility for something he did. "Does Superman tell lies?" I'll ask, and he'll immediately respond, "No", and 'fess up. That's some powerful mythology right there.
The new movie ponders the question, "Does the world need Superman?" The answer is clearly yes, and thanks to movies like this, we have him.